pattymarsh3972
June 01, 2026
"I tried placing my order, but the..."
I tried placing my order, but the website kept messing it up. The checkout page just would not work no matter what I did. It feels like it only works when it wants to, which is really frustrating when you're just trying to buy something
"Kinda disappointed when I opened the box"
The cookies themselves were good, but my first reaction when I opened the gift box was, “Oh no.” It looked a little sloppy, and a few of the wrappers were crumpled up, so it didn’t really feel gift-ready. Tasted fine, just not the best presentation if you’re sending it to someone.
"So, I sent these cookies to my..."
So, I sent these cookies to my aunt for her birthday, and she told me they were dry and a few showed up broken. She was trying to be sweet about it, but I could tell she wasn’t really impressed. For what I paid, I expected better. I probably wouldn’t order from here again.
David_bierman79
May 02, 2026
"Felt like the response took way too long"
I had a gut feeling it was going to take a while, and unfortunately it did. I ended up waiting days just to get a basic reply from customer service, which felt frustrating.
hello_delores777
April 21, 2026
"I can’t figure out how to stop the recurring orders"
I’m not sure if I missed something somewhere, but I keep getting charged for recurring orders and I can’t seem to get them to stop. Maybe there’s a cancellation step I didn’t do right, but it’s been really frustrating. At this point, I don’t think I’d order again.
morgan_Rainey76
April 15, 2026
"Shipping Made It WAY Too Pricey"
The cookies were okay, but the shipping cost made the whole thing feel not really worth it. For the total price I paid, I expected a little more. It’s a cute gift idea, for sure, but once all the fees get added on, it gets expensive FAST. I probably wouldn’t order again unless there’s a much better deal...
DavidBrenna
April 14, 2026
"Tough experience with a brand I usually love"
I’ve ordered from them before and I’ve always been a fan, so this one was disappointing. The cookies arrived with a few broken, and the box looked like it had been through a lot. I reached out to customer service thinking it would be an easy fix, but it took longer than I expected and they kept asking for more pictures and details. They did eventually offer a replacement, which I appreciate, but by that point the gift timing had already passed. I still like the brand and want to keep ordering, but for the price, I expected damaged items to be handled a little more smoothly.
evelyn_Winger89
March 15, 2026
"Got the wrong cookies"
I was disappointed when I opened my box and realized the cookies weren’t the ones I picked. I had to reach out about it, and it kind of felt like I was begging just to get what I actually ordered, which left me a little resentful about the whole experience.
Terra-jefferson
March 12, 2026
"My delivery showed up late again, which was..."
My delivery showed up late again, which was frustrating. I was hoping it’d be more reliable this time, but it ended up being the same issue.
Bert_defreitas87
March 10, 2026
"Worth it when the sales line up"
I usually have a firm rule about not paying full price if I can avoid it, so the coupons made a big difference for me. Once the sale hit, my order ended up way cheaper than I expected. For my standards, the price felt totally fair, and I was happy with it.
Michael-gutierrez
January 18, 2026
"Never know what you’re going to get"
I’ve ordered a few times, and the quality is just all over the place — sometimes it tastes fresh, other times it’s definitely stale. I’m tired of guessing every time I order, probably won’t be back.
RitaKeen_20
January 10, 2026
"So many cookie choices, and it felt legit"
I was a little worried I’d get fooled by something that looked better online than it actually was, but the site made it easy to browse. There were tons of cookie options, and I found a few gifts without much hassle. Overall, a nice experience
davidallen1543
December 12, 2025
"I was disappointed with my..."
I was disappointed with my order from Cheryl's Cookies. The cookies were dry and kinda tasted stale, like they’d been sitting around for a while before getting to me.
A few of them barely had any flavor, and the texture just felt off too. For what I paid, I really thought they’d be fresher, so yeah, I don’t think I’ll be ordering again.
MarieHess
December 10, 2025
"The box was cute, but the birthday cookies..."
The box was cute, but the birthday cookies showed up late and about half of them tasted stale. I tried reaching out for help and kept getting transferred around, which just made the whole thing more frustrating. Not really the fun surprise I was hoping for.